Allegedly with Ellison Barber

Ellison Barber

Self - Host · 30 eps

Philip C. Hamilton

Self - Criminal Defense Attorney / Self - Defense Attorney & Legal Analyst · 7 eps

Misty Marris

Self - Trial Attorney & Legal Analyst / Self - Attorney & Legal Analyst · 6 eps

Laura Jarrett

Self - NBC News Senior Legal Correspondent · 3 eps

Kristen Gibbons Feden

Self - Trial Attorney & Legal Analyst · 3 eps

Tracy Walder

Self - Former CIA Officer & FBI Special Agent · 2 eps

Evy Poumpouras

Self - Law Enforcement Analyst / Self - NBC News Law Enforcement Analyst · 2 eps

Gabby Petito

Self (archive footage) (uncredited) · 1 ep

Brian Laundrie

Self (archive footage) (uncredited) · 1 ep

Christine Marie

Self · 1 ep

Roberta Laundrie

Self (archive footage) (uncredited) · 1 ep

Chris Laundrie

Self (archive footage) (uncredited) · 1 ep

Maddie Misleh

Self - Spencer Tepe's Sister · 1 ep

Rob Misleh

Self - Spencer Tepe's Brother-In-Law · 1 ep

Elaine Bryant

Self - Columbus Police Department (archive footage) · 1 ep

Nichole Schmidt

Self - Gabby Petito's mother · 1 ep

Dan Slepian

Self - Senior Investigative Producer, Dateline · 1 ep

Dean O’Kelley

Self - Lead Detective (archive footage) · 1 ep

Colleen Beyer

Self - Sharon's Daughter (archive footage) · 1 ep

Kathy Thomas

Self - Randolph's First Wife (archive footage) · 1 ep