
The Reckoning
Two worlds, one choice
Katie Mayfield is now the mistress of Mayfield Manor. In her new world she finds herself torn between two worlds and grieves for her plain Amish life. Does Katie choose her new life or the simple heritage she left behind?
Where to Watch
Availability: United States
Stream with Subscription
Streaming availability data provided by JustWatch.
Top Cast

Katie Leclerc
Katie Lapp / Katherine Mayfield

Jacob Blair
Daniel Fisher

Chad Connell
Justin Wirth

Christopher Rosamond
Richard Davies

Chantal Perron
Wedding Planner Rhonda

Valerie Planche
Rosie Taylor

Rohan Campbell
Willie

Barb Mitchell
Mrs. Wirth

Christian Goutsis
Rex Bryant

Gerrick Winston
Selig
Alex Fellowes Smith
Tugg

Kevin Rothery
Samuel Lapp

Vanessa Holmes
Rebecca Lapp
Brian Gromoff
Fulton

Orin McCusker
Austin
James D. Hopkin
Preacher Yoder
Crew
More Like This

Runaway Romance
2018 · ★ 6.8

Love Finds You in Charm
2015 · ★ 6.2

Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
2014 · ★ 6.5

Love Finds You in Valentine
2016 · ★ 6.4

Christmas in Evergreen
2017 · ★ 6.4

An Uncommon Grace
2017 · ★ 6.5

A Godwink Christmas: Second Chance, First Love
2020 · ★ 6.9

The Wedding March
2016 · ★ 6.1

Your Fault: London
2026 · ★ 7.4

Jane Eyre
1997 · ★ 7.1

Home by Spring
2018 · ★ 6.4

A Merry Christmas Match
2019 · ★ 6.1

The Mistletoe Inn
2017 · ★ 6.0

The Outsider
2002 · ★ 5.9

The Bridges of Madison County
1995 · ★ 7.7

The Hunchback
1997 · ★ 5.9

The Lost Husband
2020 · ★ 6.6

Strangers When We Meet
1960 · ★ 6.4

Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between
2022 · ★ 6.1

The Shunning
2011 · ★ 6.1
More from This Director

The Nine Lives of Christmas
2014 · ★ 6.7

A Veteran's Christmas
2018 · ★ 6.5

Roux the Day: A Gourmet Detective Mystery
2020 · ★ 7.3

Murder, She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery
2015 · ★ 6.9

Taken Back: Finding Haley
2012 · ★ 6.7

Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery
2021 · ★ 6.8

Love at First Dance
2018 · ★ 6.0

Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Game of Cat and Mouse
2019 · ★ 7.5

A Dog Named Duke
2012 · ★ 6.6

The Road to Christmas
2006 · ★ 5.7

Ms. Matched
2016 · ★ 5.4

Deadly Deed: A Fixer Upper Mystery
2018 · ★ 6.6

Ships in the Night: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery
2021 · ★ 7.0

Three Weeks, Three Kids
2011 · ★ 6.2

Concrete Evidence: A Fixer Upper Mystery
2017 · ★ 6.7
More Featuring Katie Leclerc

A Wisconsin Christmas Pie
2025 · ★ 5.8

Cloudy with a Chance of Love
2015 · ★ 6.1

A Mother Knows Worst
2020 · ★ 5.6

The Way You Look Tonight
2019 · ★ 5.6

A Bride's Revenge
2019 · ★ 6.1

Round of Your Life
2019 · ★ 5.3

Beverly Lewis' The Confession
2013 · ★ 6.6

A Very Vermont Christmas
2024 · ★ 6.2

Christmas a la Mode
2019 · ★ 6.7

A Cape Cod Christmas
2021 · ★ 6.8

Disney Parks Christmas Day Parade
2011 · ★ 6.0

Mesmerized
2025

Caffeinated
2015 · ★ 6.0

Stars Are Already Dead
2016

Party Boat
2017 · ★ 5.8










