
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries: Blessings in Disguise
After Cheryl's 3-year engagement ends in a devastating breakup, her life is turned upside down when her aunt offers her an escape from Chicago to the Amish town of Sugarcreek. Struggling with being a fish out of water, Cheryl uncovers an unsettling secret that could disrupt the small town of Ohio. As Cheryl begins to solve the mystery, she finds community, belonging and the potential of new love. Will Sugarcreek become Cheryl's new home?
Where to Watch
Availability: United States
Stream with Subscription
Free or Ad-Supported
Streaming availability data provided by JustWatch.
Top Cast

Galadriel Stineman
Cheryl Cooper

Denise Gossett
Naomi Miller

Kevin Joy
Levi Miller

Riley Beeson
Esther Miller

J. Barrett Cooper
Terrence Cox

Micah Lynn Hanson
Hannah

Tatiana Harman
Rachel Swartz

Candace Kirkpatrick
Aunt Mitzi

Joe Kurak
Samuel Swartz

Paul Anthony McLean
Ben / Reuben

Lance E. Nichols
Chief Twitchell

Ryan O'Quinn
Seth Miller
Crew
Directors
Writers
More Like This

Love Finds You In Sugarcreek
2014 · ★ 6.5

Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin
2021 · ★ 6.1

The Deep End of the Ocean
1999 · ★ 6.6

Odd Thomas
2013 · ★ 7.0

The Village
2004 · ★ 6.5

Wicker Park
2004 · ★ 6.8

I See You
2019 · ★ 7.0

Kept Woman
2015 · ★ 6.5

The Wonder
2022 · ★ 6.6

Intrusion
2021 · ★ 5.9

Color Out of Space
2020 · ★ 6.1

The Gift
2015 · ★ 6.7

The Lie
2018 · ★ 6.4

The Others
2001 · ★ 7.6

Night Train to Lisbon
2013 · ★ 6.5

Monster Summer
2024 · ★ 6.3

Knock at the Cabin
2023 · ★ 6.2

Expectant
2020 · ★ 6.6

Who's Harry Crumb?
1989 · ★ 6.0

Brahms: The Boy II
2020 · ★ 5.8
More from This Director

How to Train Your Husband
2018 · ★ 6.1

My Sweet Holiday
2020 · ★ 5.8

Farm to Fork to Love
2021 · ★ 6.4

Finding Love in Mountain View
2020 · ★ 6.5

Finding Love in Big Sky, Montana
2022 · ★ 6.2

Finding Love in San Antonio
2021 · ★ 5.5

Rebuilding a Dream Christmas
2021 · ★ 5.7

The Skeleton's Compass
2023 · ★ 5.8

Trust Fund
2016 · ★ 4.3

It's Christmas Again
2022 · ★ 3.3

Follow Your Heart
2020 · ★ 6.9

Renovation of the Heart
2019 · ★ 6.1
More Featuring Galadriel Stineman

Ben 10: Alien Swarm
2009 · ★ 6.2

Darkness of Man
2025 · ★ 5.3

LaRoy, Texas
2024 · ★ 6.8

Fame
2009 · ★ 5.7

Night Train
2023 · ★ 5.9

Runaway Romance
2018 · ★ 6.8

The Art of Murder
2018 · ★ 6.2

Man Up
2015 · ★ 6.0

Plus One at an Amish Wedding
2022 · ★ 7.7

Betrayed at 17
2011 · ★ 6.2

Walking the Halls
2012 · ★ 4.9

The Party Is Over
2015 · ★ 4.2

Junkyard Dog
2009 · ★ 4.0

Hot Take: The Depp/Heard Trial
2022 · ★ 3.7

A Moving Romance
2017 · ★ 6.2





